• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
Prospect Genius Reviews

Prospect Genius Reviews

Reviewing digital marketing tools and services for local businesses

  • Home
  • Reviews
  • Contact Us
You are here: Home / Prospect Genius Reviews... / Prospect Genius Reviews: Angie’s List

Prospect Genius Reviews: Angie’s List

October 24, 2014 by

You’ve probably heard of Angie’s List by now. It’s an online review service containing crowd-sourced reviews of local businesses, focusing heavily on home and lawn care providers. While it claims to be a trustworthy resource that consumers can use to find reliable service providers, it has some questionable practices that lead us to understand it’s not as consumer-driven as it claims to be. In this edition of “Prospect Genius Reviews…,” we’ll explore how trustworthy Angie’s List actually is.

First, how does Angie’s List work? Based on consumer reviews, it grades businesses on a report-card-style scale from A to F. Criteria for reviews include price, quality of service, responsiveness, punctuality, and overall professionalism. While businesses aren’t required to pay to be included, Angie’s List has a paid membership requirement for consumers. They have to pay in order to view business ratings and leave reviews. Because these reviews come from paying members who have created individual profiles, the website has managed to eradicate the problems associated with anonymous authors that many other online review sites encounter. We see this as one of the few positive attributes of Angie’s List.

But while it makes sense to institute a membership fee for consumers for the sake of authenticity, we find it a tad dubious that they accept money from businesses as well. We aren’t the only ones. A September 2013 article in Forbes, titled “Why Consumer Reports Says You Can’t Trust Angie’s List,” states,

“[Angie’s List] makes a big point to say they’e consumer-driven, when in fact 70% of their revenue comes from advertising. It’s not advertising Coca Cola, it’s advertising from the companies they rate,” explained Jeff Blyskal, a senior editor for Consumer Reports. While companies do not pay to be listed on Angie’s List, companies can pay to appear higher up in the search results— which Blyskal believes compromises the validity of the Angie’s List sorting system.

Margot Gilman, a representative of Consumer Reports Money Adviser, reiterates this point: “We found that businesses with A or B ratings who also pay for advertising rise to the top of default search results on Angie’s List. It’s a big advantage.” In other words, businesses aren’t required to pay to be included, but the ones that do pay receive significant benefits. It’s no surprise that Angie’s List has focused the majority of its revenues on business advertisements.

This inevitably impacts the quality of results that consumers are presented with. Even though the favored businesses at the top of the list have ratings of A’s and B’s, there’s evidence that their ratings aren’t authentic. David Segal, author of New York Times article “A Complaint Registered, Then Expunged,” illuminates a troubling practice that Angie’s List uses to keep advertisers happy. Segal explains that when consumers post negative reviews about any of Angie’s List’s paying advertisers, Angie’s List representatives will intervene and settle the disputes to the consumers’ satisfaction. This may seem admirable, but here’s the twist: Once the disputes with paying advertisers are settled, the original negative reviews are deleted. Consumers are allowed to post new reviews, but these reviews cannot be negative, and the grade must be at least a B.

Segal theorizes that “Angie’s List doesn’t operate with a complete-narrative ethos because it would scare off advertisers.” For this reason, Prospect Genius reviews Angie’s List with great suspicion. Any online review site that claims to be at the service of consumers’ best interests should never favor payment over objectivity.

In the next edition of “Prospect Genius Reviews…,” we’ll take a look at Yodle, another online marketing company for small businesses.

Filed Under: Prospect Genius Reviews... Tagged With: angie's list, customer reviews, online advertising, paid advertising

Search our Reviews

Review Archives

  • September 2016
  • August 2016
  • July 2016
  • June 2016
  • May 2016
  • April 2016
  • March 2016
  • February 2016
  • January 2016
  • November 2015
  • October 2015
  • September 2015
  • August 2015
  • July 2015
  • June 2015
  • May 2015
  • March 2015
  • February 2015
  • January 2015
  • December 2014
  • November 2014
  • October 2014
  • September 2014
  • August 2014
  • July 2014
  • June 2014

What Drives Us?

Our passion is helping small businesses thrive. It’s why we get out of bed every day. Too many business owners are cheated and lied to every day so we see it as our duty to be a beacon of truth, a safe harbor, in an often unscrupulous industry.

Search

Review Archives

Connect With Us

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Phone
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Contact Us

Prospect Genius
279 Troy Rd
Ste 9 #102
Rensselaer, NY 12144

P: (800) 689-1273
F: (888) 488-9011
E: hello@prospectgenius.com

Serving Since

Copyright ProspectGenius and 2023